Target vs. Untargeted Ads, Rookie DYI Advertising Mistake Commonly Found In Contractors

Alexander R Li • June 17, 2022

How untargeted or board advertising decreased your conversion rate and ad cost efficiency.

This week shortly after a local networking event, I had a quick “elevator talk” with a local appliance repair contractor, he voiced his concerns about the high cost in his PPC (Pay Per Click) and that the leads are unpredictable as well, ranging from low and high ticket jobs. He wondered what are some alternative solutions to generate more leads. 


After hearing this, I noticed it was another case of a DIY advertising blunder. Oftentimes when contractors or small businesses start an advertising campaign on their own, the first thought is to advertise for the company and all of its services. The thought might be that it would be more efficient by consolidating the ad into one, however, the result is quite the opposite. 


By compiling all keywords and services provided into one ad, the sales conversion drops significantly and efficiency of ad cost also decreases dramatically. Here’s why: 


Sales conversion drops due to the fact that from the searcher’s point of view, you are not a specialized service provider. For example, if a searcher is looking for a repair on their high end refrigerator and the ads shown are an ad for a local appliance repair shop vs a specialized ad targeting refrigerator repair, the latter would without a doubt have better results. 


As for ad cost efficiency drop, the unspecialized ad is used to bid for higher cost ads which will still generate clickers, but have a higher chance of prospects opting out and choosing an alternative. Spending your ad cost with no conversion. 


So when it comes to advertising for contracting services, my advice is to first identify the high ticket items within your service, then research the costs per click using
google keyword planner. Compare the cost to revenue of each service, then create ads targeting those services specifically with a controlled budget. 


This will give you the competitive advantage over your competitors for each service they may have not targeted and a better control of budget across the board. 


When it comes to the sales writing, take into account features vs benefit. It is much more effective to describe the benefit of each targeted service instead of describing all the features of your company. Click here to read about the importance of
features vs benefits in last week's blog! 


For any questions or inquiries,
contact us now!

Credit to Good Rebels for their broad target vs target ad research.

By Local Spear Leads • November 16, 2026
Discover how the right website designer can transform your business online. Learn the key challenges businesses face and how Local Spear Leads offers tailored solutions for your unique needs.
By Local Spear Leads • November 16, 2026
Unlock the secrets of Google Business optimization to enhance your visibility and drive growth. Let Local Spear Leads guide you with expert strategies tailored for your business needs.
By Local Spear Leads • November 16, 2026
Contractors face unique challenges in the digital landscape. Discover how Local Spear Leads offers tailored solutions enabling contractors to dominate their niche through optimized marketing strategies.
By Local Spear Leads • November 9, 2026
Struggling to stand out locally online? Discover how optimizing your Google Business Profile can elevate your business visibility and attract more customers. Local Spear Leads provides simple, affordable solutions to manage this crucial digital tool effectively.
By Local Spear Leads • November 9, 2026
Discover how Google marketing can transform your small business. Learn key strategies and how Local Spear Leads can guide your journey with tailored solutions.
By Local Spear Leads • November 9, 2026
Unlock the power of Google Marketing to enhance your business visibility and boost conversions. Discover the strategies and solutions provided by Local Spear Leads that make digital marketing simple and effective.
By Local Spear Leads • November 2, 2026
Discover why contractors struggle with digital marketing and how Local Spear Leads offers tailored solutions with no long-term contracts and complete transparency.
By Local Spear Leads • November 2, 2026
Unlock the potential of Google Marketing to drive business growth. Discover actionable strategies and how Local Spear Leads can simplify the process for home service providers, solopreneurs, and growing businesses.
By Local Spear Leads • November 2, 2026
Discover how selecting the right website designer can make or break your online presence. Learn about the common challenges businesses face and how Local Spear Leads can guide you towards success with our tailored, transparent solutions.
By Local Spear Leads • October 26, 2026
Discover how effective contractor marketing can propel your business growth. Learn practical strategies and insights to overcome common challenges. With Local Spear Leads, navigating digital marketing is a breeze.